Supreme Court Considers Whether Civil Rights Act Protects L.G.B.T. Workers

There is this New York Times article that I came across yesterday and it’s titled “Supreme Court Considers Whether Civil Rights Act Protects L.G.B.T. Workers.” The article covers two cases; both of which dealing with workplace discrimination based on sexual orientation. The Supreme Court is trying to decide whether or not Title VII of the Civil Rights Act applies to LGBT employees. 

The reason it got my attention was because I couldn’t tell whether this was supposed to be some sort of clickbait or if it was an actual thing. Had you asked me before I read the article, I would have told you that I don’t even know why this case made it all the way to the Supreme Court because I couldn’t see a way how sexual orientation and gender identity could be a basis for termination. Those two things have nothing to do with a person’s ability to do their job.  

I went into the article with that mindset, hard-pressed to believe that wasn’t the belief shared by the majority. After reading it I can now understand why this case made news. Both sides of the argument made very good cases and shared hypotheticals that will definitely made me think. This issue wasn’t as cut and dry as I had thought, and part of the difficulty came from the fact that no matter what side the Court picks there will always be some group of people that will be negatively impacted by the decision. There are compelling arguments for both sides, what are your thoughts? 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Media Consolidation

Image
Media consolidation can be de fi ned as  the concentration of media ownership into the hands of fewer and fewer individuals or corporations. It is a growing issue because in 1983 90% of American media was owned by 50 companies, now that same 90% is owned by a handful of companies. An example of media consolidation is Disney owning  all of  the large networks like ABC, ESPN, The Disney Channel, Pixar,  Lucasfilm , and Marvel. They own  all of  these major networks and control what can be shown on them.  Why should you care about media consolidation? Well because for one thing, people are already losing faith and trust in mainstream media and news. The fact that these major news companies aren't even their own entities means that the people controlling them get to decide what is shown and what isn’t. The people that run these networks only care about money and making a profit, so they are only going to show things that help them accomplish...
Read more

Esports player given prize money back after Hong Kong statements

Image
Last week, a very well-known and successful game company, Activision Blizzard, disqualified professional Hearthstone player  Ng “ Blitzchung ” Wai Chung because of comments he made supporting the pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong. Ng was originally suspended for a year and Blizzard took his prize money because it was a violation of competition rules. Anything that offends the public or tarnishes Blizzard’s image would result in a ban and loss of prize money.   Of course, everyone in the gaming community was mad about the actions that Blizzard took because they thought it was censorship (This is becoming a trend now). Players aren't allowed to say what they want because of this corporate entity that is governing over them and people think it is unfair, myself included. I get the business side of things but at some  point,  people  have to  realize that the players’ opinions don’t represent the opinions of the company.     After...
Read more

Gatekeeping

Image
For this blog post I am supposed to talk about a topic that was discussed in another  groups  EOTO presentations. One topic that interested me was gatekeeping .    Gatekeeping can be defined as  the activity of controlling, and usually limiting, general access to something. And when speaking in terms of media and broadcasting it is the filtering and/or withholding information from certain groups of people. It is something that I knew of but never put time into researching it. I always thought it was an inherently bad thing but it’s not always bad. There are a lot of factors that play a role in determining what is broadcasted; things like your geographical location, the time of year, and other current events. For example, people in  North Carolina  aren't going to be told the weather in Hawaii because it isn't relevant to them.  This is why  the news is centered around Donald Trump and what he’s doing and not what t...
Read more